Crisis Communication?

Many weeks have passed since CIA Director John Ratcliffe’s surprise visit to Moscow at the end of August, yet speculation still runs rampant about the purpose of the sudden excursion. Various media outlets have all given their two cents on the matter, reporting based on anonymous insider sources. Several news agencies claim that Ratcliffe was warning Moscow against a potential attack on NATO; others argue Ratcliffe went to deter Russia from continuing to support Iran against the US; and finally, there is the concern of pushing Russia towards a peace settlement in Ukraine. The US government has yet to make an official statement on the true contents of the interaction, claiming it was merely “standard business” and not a cause for major concerns. 

In truth, Ratcliffe’s visit to Moscow probably addressed all these subjects to various degrees, but we as outsiders can only speculate. What we can all agree on is that this unannounced meeting wasn’t merely “standard business”. Normal diplomatic relations can be conducted through several channels that don’t require an impromptu face-to-face meeting. Such informal communication is often associated with crisis and looming confrontation, and not without good reason. Many analysts have already highlighted the haunting specter of the last time the US initiated such direct communications in February of 2022. Here, former President Joe Biden called President Putin to deter him from launching his invasion of Ukraine. Ultimately, this effort would be futile, but will this attempt succeed where it failed in the past? Clandestine channels offer many advantages that can potentially help resolve disputes, especially in the context of the growing tensions we live in today. Looking back to history, we can see this during one of the most infamous crises of the Cold War, the Cuban Missile Crisis.

We all know the basic story of the Cuban Missile Crisis, right? Following the discovery of Soviet nuclear missiles in Cuba in October of 1962, the US and USSR had an intense 13-day standoff that pushed the world to the brink of nuclear war. In the end, the USSR agreed to withdraw missiles from Cuba in exchange for the US withdrawing missiles from Turkey, while swearing to never invade Cuba without a direct provocation. This basic narrative is what is taught in history classes across the US, but few know the actual mechanics behind the resolution of the conflict. Some people may attribute its conclusion to the quarantine around Cuba, the removal of missiles from Turkey, or to the level-headed diplomacy between Kennedy and Khrushchev. None of these are wrong, but it is missing the most important piece that linked all of these factors together. The direct, and often informal, communication between the two heads of state outside of the public eye. 

The delicate situation demanded clandestine dispatches to allow for sensitive negotiations to occur. Now, this doesn’t mean that public pressure wasn’t used to gain an advantage, but some of the most critical proposals would come through unofficial letters between Kennedy and Khrushchev. The most consequential, the proposition to withdraw missiles from Cuba in exchange for withdrawing missiles from Turkey, would be proposed by Khrushchev in a letter to Kennedy sent on October 27, 1962. This crucial piece of correspondence paved the way for the peaceful resolution of the crisis, sparing the world from global conflict. Under-the-table diplomacy surrounding Cuba wouldn’t end following the conflict’s passing, as shown by a later Memorandum of Conversation between ambassadors on September 10th, 1963. Here, Ambassador Dobrynin delivered a message to the president so sensitive that “he had not typed it but would read from his handwritten notes.” In his message, he confronted the US regarding anonymous acts of sabotage against Cuba that the Soviets linked to the US. Resorting to an in-person exchange avoided potentially sparking another diplomatic standoff, which would have certainly occurred if open channels were used.

Coming back to today, these exchanges aren’t a one-to-one comparison. But they do give us insight into why such a method was used, and how it could be the best option to prevent further escalation. We will not know what was actually said in Moscow for decades to come, but we can hope that whatever was discussed will push our nations closer to mutual understanding. Comparing these two cases can also tell us something about the geopolitical climate we inhabit today. It is clear to all observers that we are in a world of growing tension and competition between great powers. Similar to the Cold War, we have several fronts of contention between the United States and Russia. From Western support of Ukraine, Moscow supplying Iran with targeting intelligence, and the escalating hybrid war between Europe and Russia, we are in an increasingly volatile world. We should expect to see more cloistered diplomacy as conflict proliferation continues to increase. Considering the crises that we face today, it may be policymakers' best shot to curb the growing trend of wars across the world.

Personnel