No Kings? No Dr. King.

No King’s would include no Martin Luther King Jr. These contemporary liberal organizations’ have failed to learn the correct lessons from the Civil Rights Movement, even as they praise their leaders and use their iconography. On their website they have their protests’ put into black and white, protests marching in front of John Lewis, directly creating a link to the past. Yet these liberal moderates still refuse to listen to Martin Luther King Jr. 

Despite these pictures, they are not marching in the same steps of Martin Luther King Jr. and the multitude of Civil Rights organizations like Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC), Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) etc. Organizations like No Kings, Indivisible, 50501, can do great work, but their protests are not one of them.

 

Let us begin with King’s four basic steps for any nonviolent campaign: “(1) collection of the facts to determine whether injustices are alive, (2) negotiation, (3) self-purification; and (4) direct action.” Firstly, injustices are alive, this is known. ICE has been kidnapping people and murdering innocents. Secondly, the Trump administration and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has shown that they are unwilling to negotiate as ICE has continued to brutalize American citizens and immigrants alike. But it is step three and four that No Kings, Indivisible, and other organizations have failed to take. While yes No Kings does have virtual training sessions, the majority of them are on knowing your rights and voter participation. They do have one on safety and security training focusing on deescalation and basic first aid, which is important, but this is not self-purification. These are not the same questions King asked of his followers; these are not the workshops held in the Highlander Folk School or the classes at Miami University preparing participants for Freedom Summer. King asked his fellow protesters, “‘Are you able to accept blows without retaliating?’ ‘Are you able to endure the ordeals of jail?’” These people may be protesting with John Lewis in the background, or making their pictures black and white to invoke that era but according to King they are not creating a viable nonviolent campaign. 

In addition, No Kings is not disruptive. It is at most annoying for a couple of hours and then the protest ends. Once No Kings hits the allotted time provided everyone packs up and goes home, while pretending like they resisted fascism. These liberal organizations have completely forgotten the purpose of these nonviolence campaigns; which were to invent crises, and to disrupt the status quo so much it forced the other side to come to the table. Once more King directly states to the moderates of his time, in his “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” “So the purpose of the direct action is to create a situation so crisis-packed that it will inevitably open the door to negotiation.” Liberal moderates have had over sixty-three years to sit and learn from this seminal document, yet their ears are still closed. While No King's protests ended at a certain hour, King’s campaigns ended when he either won or lost. The Montgomery bus-boycott lasted 381 days, the Birmingham campaign lasted 38 days. It is impossible to create the tension needed in a few hours, on a couple of days spread out throughout the year.

 

Yet there was one major protest movement that did listen to King’s directions and did follow in his footsteps, that being ICE Out in Minneapolis and Saint Paul. While some people see these as a part of a joint effort, this is simply just not true. One is a successful nonviolent campaign that accomplished most of its short term goals, and the other is simply a parade. After the killing of Renee Good and Alex Pretti, Minnesotans began the self-purification of themselves, asking themselves, am I willing to go to jail? Am I willing to risk my own wellbeing for my neighbors? And thankfully tens of thousands brave souls took on the risk and continued. The third step King laid out for us was fulfilled, now it was just time for direct action. Minnesotans did in fact escalate the tension to a crisis by strategically boycotting corporations that collaborated with ICE, by having a strike day where thousands did not show up to work and hundreds of businesses closed for the day. Tens of thousands participated in this protest filming ICE agents, making the ICE agents feel extremely outnumbered, unwelcomed, and frankly fearful. Unlike No Kings, which is just a short protest, ICE Out used the town square and people’s wallets to force ICE out. Using boycotts and strikes to try and force business leaders in the Twin Cities to either stop cooperating with ICE or to convince them to actively join in pushing ICE Out. In addition, ICE Out did not stop a random hour set by a permit, but ended when they succeeded. Operation Metro Surge ended on February 12th and so did the protests. ICE Out noticed the injustice taking place, was not able to negotiate with the Trump Administration, then went through the self-purification process, and finally went through with direct action, and as a result, it created a crisis when it forced the Department of Homeland Security to come to the protesters’ demands. A month later Kirsty Noem was fired from the Department of Homeland Security, in part due to the crisis that ICE Out protestors created. While, yes the DHS simply just has a new secretary, and ICE has still been active throughout the nation, the people in the Twin Cities did get ICE out.

 

Ultimately, these liberal moderates fail to understand the depth of the Civil Rights Movement, and instead of looking to the history and legacy of the Civil Rights Movement, they only see it on a surface level. They feel comfortable using the iconography, the leaders, but fail to actually use the very tactics which brought them to victory. While there have been successful nonviolent campaigns recently, No Kings is not one of them and fails to use the formula King argued for against his very own moderates.

Tags:

Personnel