Image: On September 28, 2026 an independent commission found the Premier League soccer club Manchester City guilty of 114 financial breaches. Manchester City is one of the largest teams and sports entities in the world, this year Forbes had them ranked as the seventh most valuable soccer club. Much of their financial strength, and success on the field, has come as a result of their purchase by Emirati royal and current Vice President of the UAE Sheikh Mansour in 2008. Mansour purchased the team through Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) a private equity firm that maintains that it operates independently from the government of Abu Dhabi, though leaked documents dispute this claim. Since 2008 Manchester City has won eight league titles and one Champions League titles, before the purchase the club had won neither tournament before. The Abu Dhabi linked ownership has not only rejuvenated Manchester City, but also played a vital role in the sportwashing strategy of the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The financial breaches Manchester City have been found guilty of has been described as quite serious and unprecedented. The charges included 80 encompassing financial wrongdoing and 34 charges of failure to cooperate with the league’s investigation. The Premier League’s statement after the guilty verdict says that from 2009 to 2018 the club arranged “sham” contracts and agreements to artificially inflate revenues and reduce costs. These contracts inflated revenues by more than $900 million in the time period. The purpose of these arrangements was to bypass the league’s spending rules, rules which make it impermissible for clubs to spend more than they bring in. The rules also stop a certain amount of direct investment from club owners, an attempt to stop rich owners from simply buying success. The essence of the scheme was that the club agreed commercial sponsorship deals with companies based in Abu Dhabi priced well above fair market value. The companies then only had to pay a portion of the sponsorship fees, the rest would be paid by ADUG, the owners of the club. As a result of these “sham” contracts and agreements, the club routinely misstated its revenues and expenditures to the Premier League, auditors, and regulators, clearly in an attempt to bypass the leagues’ rules. Manchester City’s financial doping was not just borne out of a competitive desire to surpass their rivals and win or glory, but part of the broader trend of sportswashing. ADUG, the firm that owns the club is tied very closely to the UAE, leaked documents have shown that the accounts of the firm are managed by the Emirate of Abu Dhabi. Executives at the club like Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak are also high level figures in the government of the UAE. The link between Manchester City’s ownership and executives with the UAE is clear, although this is denied by the club and its executives. Regardless of this public denial, the current ownership and its close relationship to the UAE shows a concerted effort to boost the image of the country globally, and make it appear forward looking and progressive. The ownership’s strategy is to use their role at the club to facilitate closer ties with Europe and the west, build influence in the region, and diversify their economy away from oil. Through a land deal with the city of Manchester, ADUG invested a substantial sum, approximately $1 billion into property development in the and around the city of Manchester. Many of the clubs main sponsors, many of whom cooperated in the “sham” contracts, are companies based in Abu Dhabi, allowing them to gain unrivaled access to viewers. Through their ties to Manchester City, the UAE is able to project an image of their country that they want the world to see. Instead of human rights abuses and roles in crises in places like Sudan, Abu Dhabi can point to the fruits of their sportwashing. This strategy helps them to win hearts in minds not just in Manchester but the world as well. Due to the unprecedented nature of this particular scandal, it is difficult to find historical comparisons. This is especially important for decision makers and regulators in deciding how Manchester City should be punished. In the soccer world, a scandal of comparable controversy and magnitude is called “Calciopoli”. The scandal emerged in 2006, involving Italian clubs, mainly Juventus, having favorable referees assigned to their games and working to influence other refereeing decisions. The final punishment for Juventus was a relegation to the lower league, years long bans for top executives, and a stripping of their 2005/06 league championship title and assignment to rival Inter Milan. This scandal, although very different in nature, provides a model for what a possible punishment could look like, and could provide some lessons. The Los Angeles Clippers salary cap circumvention scandal is much more similar, although it is very recent and in a different sport. Using similar methods as Manchester City, Clippers owner Steve Ballmer arranged no show endorsement deals for star player Kawhi Leonard. This was done in order to circumvent the team’s salary cap and pay him more than they were allowed to by the league’s rules. Unlike Manchester City’s sportswashing attempt, it is more likely that this was done in an attempt to propel the Clippers to success at the same time Ballmer funded the team’s new $2 billion dollar stadium. The harshed punishment imposed for the Clippers was the forfeiture of five first round draft picks. This forfeiture will likely make it difficult for the Clippers to remain competitive for the foreseeable future, and is the harshest punishment the NBA has imposed in a salary cap circumvention case. The Premier League and relevant decision makers will have great difficulty finding a punishment that is appropriate, as a scandal of this combined nature and magnitude is unprecedented. They will have to construct a punishment that serves as punitive on Manchester City and a deterrent for other clubs from engaging in similar practices. However, decision makers will undeniably face political pressure. The UAE has quietly threatened to withhold investments into the city of Manchester and Prime Minister Andy Burnham has made statements on the scandal that some view as sympathetic to the UAE. It is imperative though that these pressures are ignored and do not factor into a final decision. A punishment that is not comparable to the violations would damage the image of the Premier League. The league is one of the United Kingdom’s strongest cultural institutions, and damage to that institution would leave a black mark on the country as a whole. Tags: Other